Back in 1987, I read an interview with R.E.M. in Rolling Stone in which one of the boys, obviously tired of answering the question, ‘But what do the letters STAND FOR’, said, ‘Really Easy Money’. And sure, why not? They were on the cover of Rolling Stone, hailed as the best band in America.
And yes, I love(d) R.E.M. with pretty much every fiber of my being at the tender young age of 12. In eighth grade, when I got glasses for the first time, I wore my pink REM bicycle shirt to give me strength. My best friend in middle and high school poured over liner notes, studied J.M. Stipes clues expecting to find a treasure map leading us to wry sophistication.
I’ve collected their albums, their singles, their shirts, and been an on-again off-again member of the fan club for ages. I once called ‘Peter Buck’ in Atlanta (circa ‘87, pre-Rolling Stone cover) and spoke to Peter Buck’s dad, a gracious man.
I can’t deny a feeling of being let down over the last 10-12 years by the boys. A short list of concerns:
- Broken Promises – Bill Berry left the band, and the remaining members soldiered on despite promising they’d break up if that every happened. Similarly, the promises to break up on Dec. 25, 1999, and to never print their lyrics
- Declining output/declining quality From 1983-96, they released 10 albums, the worst of which (in my opinion, ‘Monster’) was still pretty good. From 1996-2008, they’ve released 4 albums (if you count tomorrow’s release of ‘Accelerate’)
- Rock Star-ism – According to Jim DeRogatis of ‘Sound Opinions’, at this year’s SXSW festival R.E.M. also taped an episode of Austin City Limits, and the taping was held up over an hour because someone brewed J.M. Stipe the wrong kind of espresso
- Greatest Hits – 2003’s ‘In Time (88-03) & ‘And I Feel Fine – The IRS Years (82-87). Yeah, not a fan of the GH packages/tours
Ok. Here’s the thing though, I really really dislike those guys who’re like, ‘Oh yeah, they used to be great, but now they suck.” I hate those guys, because when I was getting into R.E.M. (1986), everyone was saying that ‘Life’s Rich Pageant’ was no ‘Chronic Town’. Fuck those guys.
So, in an effort to give my old heroes a legit chance, I’m going to, starting today, listen to every R.E.M. studio album, in order, and give an honest review. I’m not going to tackle the B-side or greatest hits compilations. I will kick it off with their first EP, and work my way up through ‘Accelerate’. I will do my best to weed out nostalgic pap and give an honest review of their work.
As a quick refresher, here’s how it’ll look -
1982 – Chronic Town
1983 – Murmur
1984 – Reckoning
1985 – Fables of the Reconstruction
1986 – Life’s Rich Pagent
1987 – Document
1988 – Green
1991 – Out of Time
1992 – Automatic for the People
1994 – Monster
1996 – New Adventures in Hi-Fi
1998 – Up
2001 – Reveal
2004 – Around the Sun
2008 – Accelerate
Wish me luck!
